How to Accurately Measure the Flow of Liquid or Gas

By Thomas Devaraj PhD, Senior Application Specialist, PTC

Ever wonder how to measure the flow of liquid or gas accurately?

More importantly, can you be certain that your measuring devices are performing accurately?

It is well known that in Formula 1 races, the fuel  is measured in kilograms rather than litres. This is because at different temperatures & pressures, fuel will have different volumes. For the same reason, jet fuel is usually measured  in a similar manner.

In my frequent encounters with oil industry professionals, I came across a similar problem that requires frequent checks and close monitoring to ensure that the highest degree of accuracy is maintained.

Gas pipelines are often shared for moving this valuable commodity around. Hence there is a good reason why the equipment that measures the flow of oil or gas needs to be accurate.  And with energy prices climbing ever higher, the margin for error is even smaller.

Even though the job of monitoring flow is performed by dedicated flow computers, it’s still crucial to check their accuracy based on operating conditions. Such an example using Mathcad to verify flow measurements is presented below.

Critical factors such as pressure, temperature, liquid and gas properties need to be taken in consideration to accurately determine mass flow rates.

Historically, such calculations were often done using a variety of different tools and  methods, Excel high on that list. The issues of limited transparency and lack of audit-ability of excel based approaches are ones I hear all too often.

Mathcad’s open and transparent document based approach to calculations makes the process of creating, updating, validating and re-using of calculations straightforward.

This is beneficial as often such projects involve collaborative efforts of engineers and consultants from different companies exchanging, auditing or reviewing complex calculations.

Ultimately, Mathcad provides an ideal platform for doing so, safely, efficiently and most importantly of working with confidence.

Finally, the financial implications of not performing the flow measurements accurately is clearly one to take note of and it emphasizes the importance of getting those calculations right!

Our thanks & credit for the worksheet content go to Smith Rea Energy Ltd, Aberdeen, UK

About Bettina Giemsa

I graduated from Ruhr University in Bochum, Germany, with a Master of Arts in American Studies, Japanese, Economics * Started my career in Marketing on the agency side, spending almost 3 years in media planning * Ran Marketing at ITEDO Software GmbH, Germany from 2001-2006 where I first got in touch with the CAD business * Became part of the PTC Marketing organization when ITEDO was acquired by PTC in October 2006 * Last, but not least, I am the mother of a 4-year-old, and sometimes wonder which is harder to cope with: a little girl with a temper or a busy workday…
This entry was posted in Tips & Tricks and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to How to Accurately Measure the Flow of Liquid or Gas

  1. Philip Oakley says:

    There are standardised excel worksheets for the error analysis [from Guide to Uncertainty in Measurement 'ISO' JCGM 100:2008].
    However, if you select multiple tabs so you can print a group of them, you also get ‘write through’ for free. So in the latest Excel versions where the tabs selected only show in soft gray rather that hard black, you can easily miss the fact that the new number you type in to the top sheet’s cell is copied through to all the other selected sheets. Not what you had expected.. all the other error calcs now have unexpected values in them! Another example of the error potential in Excel…

  2. eng moshe zadik says:

    With due respect, being in the instrumentation and control business for more then 30 years
    I can not accept that the figures presented in the output section can be measured to the 1/10 of a 1/1000. these calculations are nice but cannot be varified

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s